In this episode, I wrap up our 4 part series on heart rate training.
I take what we’ve learned over the past few episodes and apply it to your own unique situation, so you can create your own heart rate training zones.
A quick recap…
In episode 26, I introduced the series on heart rate training and how it can benefit your running.
In episode 27, I shared the background information we need to understand how and why heart rate training works. We also looked at the key metrics that you can use to help measure and set up your training zones.
In episode 28, I shared the metrics we need to calculate your resting heart rate, maximum heart rate, and lactate threshold.
In the previous episode, I went over how to calculate your maximum heart rate by using the Joel Friel Lactate Threshold Estimation Test and the Phil Maffetone Maximum Aerobic Function (MAF) Test.
But, before we dig into establishing you heart rate training zones, I want to talk about what we should do if our calculated metrics contradict each other or if you feel like your numbers are off.
This can be a common situation, and we had a great thread going in the RunBuzz Facebook group on the topic. A listener, named John, (thank you John), mentioned that he was getting a big variance in results between the Phil Maffetone MAF formula estimation and Joe Friel’s 30 minute lactate threshold estimation.
In theory, your lactate threshold and your maximum aerobic threshold numbers should be close. But, in John’s case, his variance between the two was as much as 30 beats per minute. As you can imagine, this lead to questions about what number he should use when setting up his training zones.
For John, the MAF formula indicated a much lower heart rate than expected. This result put the approach in question again, since it was so low that it could be hit at very low running speeds or even just by walking!
How do we address such a problem?
This is the way I would approach these types of results:
Calculating heart rate training zones with MAF is easy. You simply take your MAF number and stay below it by 5-10 beats – then you’re good to go.
If, however, you go over the MAF number, you’re training anaerobically. For those who want to get more specific about your heart rate training zones, we’ll use Friels’ approach a little later.
A common problem with MAF is that many people struggle with staying at that low of a heart rate, one based purely on an estimation – especially beginners.
Because it can take a few years to truly maximize your base, your heart rate may go over your MAF more easily than more seasoned runners. But that’s the beauty and curse of this method. If you follow it strictly, you will maximize your base building potential. Plus, in reality, many of us probably should be slowing down.
If you find your heart rate is easily going over your MAF number, I would suggest increasing it by 5 beats per minute until you can get to an easy run. You will need to play with this a bit.
Again, it’s less about finding that perfectly exact spot with your heart rate than it is about using your heart rate monitor as a tool to keep you in range. This way, your intensity doesn’t creep up higher than needed for your training purposes.
You may also find that, as your fitness base gets better, you will be able to keep your heart rate lower, even though you’re running faster.
In other words, you’ll adjust to your training methods and get more accurate results to apply to the MAF formula.
As mentioned in episode 28, the Friel method uses a 30 minute field test. Now, in my opinion, Friel’s test is harder than the MAF estimation – and it should be.
Friel is looking for your lactate threshold. This is where you reach a threshold in which lactate accumulates faster that your body can clear it.
If this is the first time you’ve listened to this podcast, or if you did’nt catch the previous episodes, you may want to go back and listen to those first. I go into a lot more detail on what lactate threshold is and why it’s such an important metric.
In Friel’s method, zones are calculated as a percentage of the lactate threshold heart rate (LTHR).
Using Friel’s method, once you have your LTHR numbers, your zones would look something like this:
Zone 1 – Less than 85% of LTHR – these are recovery workouts
Zone 2 – 85% to 89% of LTHR – long workouts – very aerobic
Zone 3 – 90% to 94% of LTHR – high aerobic
Zone 4 – 95% to 99% of LTHR – race pace up to 1 hour – don’t train here too much
Zone 5 – 100% and higher of LTHR – all Zone 5 are sprints, hills, anaerobic short intensities
If it were me, I would take both of these metrics, if you can.
However, if you’re a newer runner and don’t have the endurance to run at least a full hour, I would start off with the MAF estimation. I myself chose MAF for the same reasons I mentioned earlier: it’s connection to base building.
In actuality, I would probably start you off on MAF even if you were training up to a marathon distance if you were still in a base building stage.
Now, if you’re able to run marathon or half marathon distances (or, basically, if you have a very solid base for your race distance), then I would recommend starting off with the Friel test.
Because it’s extremely beneficial to have a good grasp of where your lactate threshold is, especially if you’re incorporating training runs that involve anaerobic components.
But, regardless of what values you initially start with, you should challenge these zones with some real observation and by looking at real data.
Don’t take the measurements as gospel straight out of the book. That, is exactly what so many people do and then feel like they aren’t allowed to adjust them.
My advice is to apply a series of test runs to challenge and assess your identified training zones. Collect heart rate data along the way and match that up with your feedback on how each run actually felt. Relative to your heart rate data, was the run too easy or too hard? Don’t do this just once but over several runs. If something still seems too easy or too hard, then modify the zones from there.
As you get more in shape, you will get faster, even though you’re maintaining the same heart rate. That’s why using the MAF method requires more patience than the Friel test. The results can take some time to generate, but you will improve, and you will do so in the maximum way possible because your intensity will be set correctly in order to facilitate this change.
By using a combination of tools – heart rate, effort, testing, and so on – we can dial in your heart rate zones, regardless of whether or not you use the MAF or Friel approach as a starting point.
PaceBuilders™ Training System – A complete, end to end, custom training program for runners. Get unlimited ‘customized’ training plans with unlimited modifications that match your lifestyle and running goals. PLUS, get access to video training sessions and unlimited support so you can blast through your running goals.
Customized Training Plans For Any Race Or Distance – 100% handwritten custom training plans written around your unique situation. Don’t settle for generic training plans found in books, magazines, or online. Our training plans take your history, your goals, your fitness profile and your lifestyle into consideration. Includes free access to Final Surge, where you can view and log your workouts anywhere you have access to a web browser, or use the mobile app.
Runner’s Toolkit – Get access to 30 days of free coaching tips by email and get your #1 running question personally answered by me, just for signing up. Plus get free access to our private Facebook community where other RunBuzz community members gather for support, camaraderie and general shenanigans.
Find out how you can support RunBuzz’s mission to bring quality running content (educational, inspirational, etc) to the running community. Help support me in my mission to make every runner regardless of age, size and ability a better runner.
If you’d like to get RunBuzz delivered automatically to your smartphone or podcast player at no charge to you, please subscribe using your preferred method below:
If you’d like the direct RSS feed for your own favorite RSS Podcast Player, click here to get it!
If you get a chance, please leave me an honest review and rating on iTunes by clicking here. (This helps me get the show up in the rankings and I’d deeply appreciate it. 🙂 )
I Appreciate Your iTunes Reviews!
Getting a 5 star rating and/or written review is incredibly important for this show. It helps with ranking and with generating the necessary exposure that gets this podcast out in front of other runners.
But it is even more important to me!
I read each and every comment and really take them all to heart. They provide encouragement that what I am doing is getting noticed and that the show is getting listened to.
I am so thankful to those who have recently gone into iTunes to provide a five star rating and written a review of RunBuzz Radio.
If you can and would like to provide a rating and/or write a review (there’s certainly no obligation), then you can do so by following these instructions:
1) Go to the show’s iTunes Page or search “RunBuzz” from iTunes if you aren’t already a subscriber.
2) Open the page in the iTunes app, and click on the number of stars for the rating you think I deserve.
3) Write a sentence or two to share your comments.
Thank you SO Much!